Phân tích sơ tác phẩm A Bar at the Folies-Bergère

Đó là bức tranh nổi tiếng A Bar at the Folies-Bergère (1882) của danh họa Manet
Đây là bức tranh vẽ cô gái ở quán bar và khung cảnh bên trong nhà hát tên là Folly Bergere được phản chiếu qua tấm gương phía sau lưng cô hầu bàn.

Bạn có cảm giác được điều gì đặc biệt khác thường không?
・Hình ảnh phía trước người đàn ông và bóng dáng phía sau cô hầu bàn được phản chiếu trong tấm gương sau lưng theo một đường chéo.

・Thế nhưng người đàn ông đứng trước cô hầu bàn trong gương thì lại không đứng đối diện với cô ấy. Vậy người đàn ông này ở đâu?
・Vị trí và sự sắp sếp của mấy cái chai trong gương cũng không giống nhau.
Nếu nhìn thẳng ngay từ hướng đối diện với cô ấy, thì có thể nhìn thấy hình ảnh phản chiếu qua gương nghiêng như vậy không?

Từ thời điểm công bố bức tranh, đã có nhiều suy đoán xoay quanh bức tranh bí ẩn này. Cũng có người cho rằng bức tranh chẳng qua được vẽ tùy ý để làm tăng thêm vẻ đẹp bức tranh mà thôi.
Tuy nhiên, từ góc nhìn chính xác của sử gia mỹ thuật người Úc Malcolm Park ta đã có thể thấy được bức tranh này rất chân thực.
Người đàn ông trong gương thực chất đang nhìn về phía bên trái cô hầu bàn và không hề hướng đến trò chuyện với cô ấy. Ông được cho là đang nhìn người phụ nữ mặc đồ trắng (gái gọi) ở phía bên trái cái gương. Ánh mắt của người đàn ông và cô hầu bàn hoàn toàn không hề giao nhau.
Tuy nhiên, nhờ vào sự đánh lừa thị giác do sử dụng các góc độ của gương nên đã nhầm tưởng người đàn ông và cô hầu bàn trong gương đang đối mặt và nhìn nhau. Điều này thực sự thú vị.


Liên quan đến việc đánh lừa ảo ảnh này, vào năm 2000 trung tâm Getty ở Los Angeles đã thử tái hiện lại khung cảnh này để chứng minh tính chân thực trong bức tranh của danh họa Manet.

xem thêm tại ca cuoc bong da: 

https://www.google.com.nf/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx

https://www.google.gl/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx

https://www.google.im/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx

https://www.google.gg/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx

https://www.google.sm/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx

https://www.google.com.bn/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx

https://www.google.sc/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx

https://www.google.cg/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx

https://www.google.dm/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx

https://www.google.dj/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx

https://www.google.tl/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx

https://www.google.cv/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
https://www.google.bf/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
https://www.google.com.vc/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
https://www.google.com.ai/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
https://www.google.bj/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
https://www.google.ml/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
https://www.google.to/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
https://www.google.so/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
https://www.google.co.ck/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
https://www.google.cf/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
https://www.google.gy/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
https://www.google.com.tj/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
https://www.google.pn/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
https://www.google.st/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
https://www.google.td/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
https://www.google.vu/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
https://www.google.tk/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
https://www.google.com.sb/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
https://www.google.com.sl/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
https://www.google.ne/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
https://www.google.nr/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
https://www.google.ki/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
https://www.google.ga/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
https://www.google.nu/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
https://www.google.ac/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://maps.google.com/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.pl/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.ca/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.nl/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.com.br/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.com.au/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.cz/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.ch/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.be/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.at/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.se/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.com.tw/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.com.hk/url?q=httpsfive88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.dk/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.hu/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.fi/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.com.tr/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.com.hk/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.com.ua/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.com.mx/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.pt/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.co.nz/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.co.th/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.no/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.com.ar/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.ro/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.co.za/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.co.id/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.sk/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.ie/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.gr/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.com.my/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.cl/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.com.vn/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.com.ph/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.bg/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.co.kr/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.co.il/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.lt/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.si/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.hr/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.com/url?q=https://gfive88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.ae/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.rs/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.com.sa/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.com.co/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.ee/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.lv/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.com.pe/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.mu/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.co.ve/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.lk/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.com.pk/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.lu/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.by/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.com.ng/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.com.np/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.com.uy/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.tn/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.com.ec/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.com.bd/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.co.ke/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.dz/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.co.cr/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.com.lb/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.com.do/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.com.gh/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.com.gt/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.com.pr/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.ba/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.is/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.kz/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.com.mt/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.com.py/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.co.ug/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.co.bw/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.com.kw/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.com.kh/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.ge/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.jo/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.com.sv/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.com.bo/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.com.ni/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.com.pa/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.cat/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.hn/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.mk/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.ad/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.com.bh/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.ci/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.co.ma/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.com.cy/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.com.qa/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.li/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.com.na/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.iq/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.com.jm/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.am/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.tt/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.cm/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.md/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.me/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.az/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.co.tz/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.co.zw/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.mg/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.sn/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.ps/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.mn/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.mv/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.com.et/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.com.om/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.com.cu/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.com.bz/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.sr/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.bs/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.la/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.je/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.com.mm/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.cd/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.com.ly/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.as/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx
http://images.google.rw/url?q=https://five88.net/the-loai/du-doan-xo-so.aspx